| 265* | WW Armstrong | Melbourne v St Kilda | Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1603 |
| 200* | PA McAlister | East Melbourne v St Kilda | St Kilda Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1593 |
| 188* | VS Ransford | Melbourne v University | University Oval, Melbourne | vca1623 |
| 173 | FA Baring | East Melbourne v Prahran | East Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1577 |
| 166* | RL Park | University v Prahran | Toorak Park, Melbourne | vca1556 |
| 166 | WW Armstrong | Melbourne v South Melbourne | South Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1586 |
| 152 | BL Cohen | St Kilda v Richmond | St Kilda Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1575 |
| 149* | GEJ Healy | Prahran v North Melbourne | Toorak Park, Melbourne | vca1566 |
| 142* | FC Yeomans | Northcote v St Kilda | St Kilda Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1610 |
| 130 | FC Yeomans | Northcote v Fitzroy | Westgarth Street Oval, Melbourne | vca1591 |
| 129 | AG Moyes | Essendon v South Melbourne | Windy Hill, Melbourne | vca1588 |
| 129* | JL Ellis | Prahran v St Kilda | St Kilda Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1622 |
| 126 | LD Ferguson | St Kilda v Richmond | St Kilda Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1575 |
| 124* | VS Ransford | Melbourne v St Kilda | Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1603 |
| 123 | C Kiernan | Fitzroy v St Kilda | Fitzroy Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1564 |
| 118 | ER Mayne | East Melbourne v Carlton | Princes Park, Melbourne | vca1582 |
| 116* | GA Davies | Essendon v Carlton | Windy Hill, Melbourne | vca1578 |
| 116 | BA Onyons | Melbourne v Fitzroy | Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1579 |
| 116* | AE Liddicut | Fitzroy v South Melbourne | Fitzroy Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1597 |
| 113 | WF Rohsburn | North Melbourne v Melbourne | Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1607 |
| 112 | EV Carroll | Northcote v St Kilda | St Kilda Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1610 |
| 109* | LE Downs | Carlton v University | University Oval, Melbourne | vca1569 |
| 108 | HCA Sandford | Melbourne v Fitzroy | Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1579 |
| 108 | WD Saltau | University v St Kilda | St Kilda Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1587 |
| 107* | WW Armstrong | Melbourne v Carlton | Princes Park, Melbourne | vca1570 |
| 106* | EL Carroll | Essendon v University | Windy Hill, Melbourne | vca1601 |
| 105 | A Kenny | South Melbourne v Richmond | South Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1580 |
| 104* | HJ Richardson | Richmond v Northcote | Westgarth Street Oval, Melbourne | vca1561 |
| 104* | WG Sutherland | Carlton v South Melbourne | Princes Park, Melbourne | vca1606 |
| 103* | LA Cody | Fitzroy v St Kilda | Fitzroy Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1564 |
| 103* | E Tait | Fitzroy v Northcote | Westgarth Street Oval, Melbourne | vca1591 |
| 102 | JL Ellis | Prahran v Essendon | Toorak Park, Melbourne | vca1585 |
| 101* | S Sykes | South Melbourne v St Kilda | St Kilda Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1562 |
| 101* | WJG Woodbury | Northcote v Fitzroy | Westgarth Street Oval, Melbourne | vca1591 |
| 100* | HHG Bracher | North Melbourne v South Melbourne | North Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1554 |
| 100* | MD Hotchin | St Kilda v University | St Kilda Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1587 |
